India allows 'living wills' for terminally ill

Health experts welcomed the decision of the SC but said strict regulations must be put in to prevent abuse of the living will. representative image

A "living will" is made by a person, in his normal state of mind, seeking voluntary euthanasia in case of terminal illness, if he or she reaches an irreversible vegetative state.

The top court, in its last year's verdict, said there was no justification to keep the enforcement of Lokpal Act suspended till the proposed amendments, including on the issue of the Leader of Opposition in Lok Sabha, were cleared by the Parliament.

A five judge constitution bench of the Supreme Court said passive euthanasia is permissible; the court has framed detailed guidelines using its extraordinary power. The Supreme Court with a strict guideline to govern has permitted the passive euthanasia. Euthanasia can be active or passive in form and depending in the legal framework of a state, euthanasia is carried out in active or passive manner. However, in case of difference of opinion or rejection by the Medical Board on account of ambiguity in the advanced directive, the family or the hospital can approach the High Court that will expeditiously hear and decide the case.

What is the ruling all about? .

However, in a landmark judgement on Friday, 9 March 2018, the Supreme Court of India not only allowed the removal of life support for patients who are suffering from incurable comas or are terminally ill, but also recognized the concept of "living will".

"How can a person be told that he/she does not have right to prevent torture on his body?" A person can not be forced to live on support of ventilator.

Advocate Prashant Bhushan, appearing for the NGO, said since a patient in a coma can not express his or her wishes, the law should allow him or her to put down in writing in advance that he or she should not be tortured. Attempted suicide is now punishable by up to one year in jail under Section 309 of the Indian Penal Code, but, according to the Times of India, the government is considering revising that law.

What is a living will?

More news: Gandhi statue damaged in Kannur, police detain mentally unstable man

Also termed as "advance medical directive", it is a direction issued by an individual that "he or she shall or shall not be given medical treatment in future when or he she becomes terminally ill".

It is now legal in India for terminally ill patients to refuse medical treatment. It includes authorizing his/her family to withdraw life support system in case a medical board declared that they were beyond medical help.

The SC provided for stringent guidelines for preparing and giving effect to "living will", to prevent possible misuse by greedy relatives eyeing the patients property by involving multiple medical boards comparising several experts and even judicial officers. It had cited examples of various countries in disallowing creation of living will by patients. The right to die with dignity, the NGO had argued was a Fundamental Right guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution.

Though the government took the lead in decriminalising suicide and is ready with a draft legislation formalising passive euthanasia, it struck a contradictory note in opposing living wills, essentially a person's desire to exit from life at a point of no return.

Aruna Shanbaug: The KEM nurse who was strangulated and sodomised by a sweeper in 1973 leading to her spending the rest of her life in vegetative state drew a wide spread attention.

The court also considered such cases where no living will or directive is left behind. On October 11, 2017, hearing was concluded and judgment reserved. On July 15th of the same year, a five-judge bench was commenced to hear the plea. He dies during the pendency of the case.

After nearly two years of that, on February 15th, 2016 thecentreopined that it is a deliberate issue and the five judges bench led by the Chief Justice of India Dipak Misra heard the argument and reversed the previous verdict. "But while the government was in favour of passive euthanasia, as demonstrated by the drafting of the 2016 bill, it was silent on the matter of the living will".

Related News:



Most liked

Cleveland Browns Trade: Damarious Randall fits at corner or free safety
The Green Bay Packers certainly didn't trade Damarious Randall on Friday night for salary cap reasons. He played in 15 games, completing just 53.6 percent of his passes for 2,894 yards and 11 touchdowns.

Uhuru Kenyatta, Raila Odinga Move To Reconcile
Embassy. "I think the leaders want to say to [Tillerson], 'Look, we've buried the hatchet, we've moved forward". Political analyst and writer Patrick Gathara said such a dialogue is still needed despite Friday's meeting.

Zinedine Zidane believes Gareth Bale is fundamental to Real Madrid
Ronaldo scored twice, his second six minutes from the end, as Real won 2-1 and avoided another slip-up in La Liga. Eibar battled back after the break and levelled up on 50 minutes when Ivan Ramis headed home a corner.

Half goals see Chelsea to victory over Crystal Palace
Roy Hodgson sent on Palace talisman Wilfried Zaha for the second half in place of Benteke, and it nearly paid off instantly.

PlayStation 4 update lets parents boot kids from playing
The new software doesn't bringing any sweeping UI changes; but there are some interesting features worth exploring. Please note performance will vary, as games are optimized differently to take advantage of the power of PS4 Pro.

A Wrinkle In Time With Jennifer Lee
Characters zip from one planet to the next with little connective tissue, and we must accept each narrative jolt at face value. But for now, she hopes " A Wrinkle in Time " connects with moviegoers and encourages them to follow their dreams.

Carolina Panthers trade for veteran receiver with history of big plays, drops
The 6-foot, 209-pounder stepped up his game in the playoffs, however, catching 13 passes for 157 yards and a TD. Worley will join fellow corners Sidney Jones , Ronald Darby , and Jalen Mills fighting for playing time.

Cleveland Browns trade for Miami Dolphins WR Jarvis Landry, per reports
The Bills signed Taylor to a five-year contract extension before the 2016 season that could have allowed him to earn $90 million. Acquiring Landry has likely changed those plans and the Browns can address a multitude of other needs.

Fortnite App: 8 Things to Know About Fortnite for iPhone & Android
Requirements for Fortnite Battle Royale on iOS? Android users have to wait a few months to get in on the fun. Those chosen will receive an email with instructions on how to download the game to their device.

After Supreme Court verdict, Hadiya leaves for Kerala
Justice Chandrachud, however, said that "the moment we step into the realm of public law, we are stepping into a unsafe domain". The SC had said earlier that Hadiya is an adult and her marriage to Shefin Jahan can not be questioned.

Waymo self-driving trucks to start hauling cargo next week
Waymo joins Uber and Tesla in the race to develop autonomous trucks and disrupt the traditional trucking industry. Waymo's mission has always been to make it safe and easy for people and things to move around.

US Holocaust Museum rescinds prize to Myanmar leader
The museum said Suu Kyi failed to live up to the standards it expected of the award's recipients. The museum has also published findings that include "mounting evidence of genocide".

Karti Chidambaram Case: Delhi Court Grants CBI Another 3 Days of Custody
Karti was able to speak to them for ten minutes in front of the investigating officer before taken away by the agency sleuths. CBI has been successful in getting custody of Karti Chidambaram till March 12 2018 from a special court today.

California veteran's home on lockdown after reports of shots fired
CNN reports that the center is home to around 1,000 retired veterans and is the largest such facility in the country. The Napa County Sheriff's Department issued an alert to residents at 10.30am warning them to avoid the area.

'Personal insults' behind Warner-De Kock row
Reports had claimed that the spat started with the Australian vice-captain celebrating the run-out of AB de Villiers on day 4 of the first Test.